The Eminem Show? Good Album or Not?

[ha'rizon]

So me and Mike Hosea are arguing..

I was quoting some shit from "The Way I Am" and "Stan"..

We both agreed MMLP was classic..

Then he says, thats the last he liked of Eminem..

So Im askin for opinions..

Cause I thought the Eminem Show was a good album..

Please, no comments about Encore, I dunno about that shit, lol..

But "Til I Collapse".. "Soldier".. "White America".. too many

Shit is an EASY 4 MIC.. if not more

let the arguments begin

[Demise Of All]

havn't heard alot of it but it's ight i think dat the slim shady LP is his best album

[flump]

id idnt say MMLP was classic, i said it was the last cd with shit i liked form him

eminem show = i wanna fart in his mouth while he inhales deeply

[ha'rizon]

Mmlp = Classic

[Emerge]

Slim Shady LP = Meh
Marshal Mathers LP = Dope as Fuck
The Eminem Show = Nice, not super dope some skippable tracks
Encore = Puta Mierda

[ha'rizon]

Slim Shady LP = Meh
Marshal Mathers LP = Dope as Fuck
The Eminem Show = Nice, not super dope some skippable tracks
Encore = Puta Mierda

^ Cant put it better than that..

[Born To Kill]

Slim Shady LP = Meh
Marshal Mathers LP = Dope as Fuck
The Eminem Show = Nice, not super dope some skippable tracks
Encore = Puta Mierda

Yeah...that about nails it.

[David Lama]

the eminem show was a great album. better than ANY album dropped in 2005 so far, its better than most albums these days, i dont see why so many people dont like it. it was dope.

and Slim Shady LP was dope as fuck, a classic

wtf at someone saying meh??

and infinite was a classic too.

[RXL]

till i collapse has ONE of the dopest verses in hip hop

a lot of the songs were skippable

but it was a decent album

i unno, for some reason i just didint like it as much as mmlp which was a bad ass cd, but not classic in my opinion

[Chris Black]

I hated the production on The Eminem Show. There were a couple good beats, but I hated them, for the most part. His style changed and it worked for good in some places and for bad in others. There were good joints, but most were bad, in my oppinion. 2/5

I thought all his 8 Mile songs were dope though. That's the last time I felt him - on the 8 Mile soudtrack.

[ha'rizon]

^ Slim Shady was ill, agreed

[RXL]

the eminem show was a great album. better than ANY album dropped in 2005 so far, its better than most albums these days, i dont see why so many people dont like it. it was dope.

and Slim Shady LP was dope as fuck, a classic

wtf at someone saying meh??

and infinite was a classic too.

wow infinate a classic?

i dont think so, not no where near for me

meh, diffrent strokes

[flump]

word infinate sucked good sign of a stan is if they say infinate was classic, msot people dont even consider it one of his cds lol

[Dante_Grim]

Infinie = Dope as hell
SSLP = Classic
MMLP = Classic
Devil's Night = Good Album, a few skippable Tracks
Eminem Show = Great Album, just not as good as his other Lp's
-----------
Anything after the Eminem Show sucked.

[David Lama]

word infinate sucked good sign of a stan is if they say infinate was classic, msot people dont even consider it one of his cds lol

stan? lmao.. hell no

the album was dope., i relate and like so many of the songs on it.

there was a couple of tracks i didnt like, but the ones i did like made up for it.